Here are some suggestions to find online party items from some of the most complete party stores.

Celebrate Express offers great Elmo Party Supplies

We found this cute pinata at Shindigz Elmo Pull Pinata Each

Birthday in a Box carries Elmo Favor Sets

Make your own or here is an option for a personalized invitation. Sesame Friends Personalized Invitation

Color scheme is usually red for Elmo. Primary colors like yellow or orange complement this nicely.

Elmo Party hats

Primary colored streamers.

Red and orange balloons

Elmo themed or red napkins, plates, cups, and cutlery.

Elmo or Cookie Monster posters or birthday banners.

Sand buckets decorated and filled with goodies for favors.

Red, Yellow, Blue bowls for small snacks.

Show in above photo which we were given written permission to use are some wonderful ideas from Frosted Events

Box of crayons and color book

Bubbles

Mini board books

Sesame Street washcloth

Rubber Ducks for the tub

In a rush to put together a goody bag? Here is quick and cute option from Celebrate Express. Hooray for Elmo Party Favor Box

These cookies are from Earth's Best and kids love them.

Organic Sesame Street Letter of the Day Cookies

Fruit Punch

Cookies especially if Cookie Monster is a favorite.

Pizza (Elmo's favorite food) Cut into strips for young toddlers.

Baby Carrots (they sell microwave ones that are extra small)

Goldfish and pretzel mix

Red or blue Jelly Bellies or M & M's

Red, Blue or Yellow Jello Jigglers (use Jello's letter cutters or fun shaped cookie cutters)

Use star and heart shaped cookie cutters to make fun shaped sandwiches

If this is a young toddler group you probably want to select only 1 or 2 simple games or activities.

Decoupage Letters

Add buttons, silk flowers or rhinestones. These letters are from Paper Source CraftsClick on photo for how to.

---

Water Globe

Use this ideas with Elmo Cake toppers. Water Globe Click on link or photo for complete directions.

---

Decorate sugar cookies as an activity with Royal Icing

---

Play "Elmo Says" or "Cookie Monster Says" (following Simon Says rules)

---

Fill a clear jar with either cookies or Goldfish (Dorothy) and have children guess how many there are. The closest to the correct number is the winner.

---